BLOG.CATEGORY: Going Beyond

Andrew Hollingsworth

Unconscious Bias - where does it come from?

TSSA members attending a rally

ow long has Unconscious Bias (UB) been around I ask myself? Probably as long as humans have? There are systems of understanding ‘people’ that date back several thousands of years so it’s nothing new. At the same time, I ask myself the ‘nature Vs nurture’ question and how much of it is contributes to your unconscious bias (UB)? I’m sure the majority of people would suggest that it’s more biased towards nurture (there’s a nice bit of generalisation for you - see we can’t help it - lol). By the way, I wouldn’t dispute the profound impact that nurture has on UB however I’d also like to explore a concept that could shed some light on the nature argument. Keep reading to find out more...

About 8-9yrs ago I started working on designing and developing a type of personality/psychometric tool called Archeotype© that would be a little bit different to what was already on the market. There is an abundance of these sorts of instruments that assess all types of people-orientated elements but I had reached a point (and so had many other people) where I was questioning the inadvertent outcome of being ‘put in a box’ as a result of the findings. (I must add, by the way, I’m a huge fan of these instruments, I use them a lot in my role as a consultant/coach) but nevertheless, main times, they become ‘self-fulfilling prophecies’.

As human beings, we operate a lot by ‘rule of thumb’ as opposed to purely, objective information – just think about ‘impulse buys’... many are designed to play to our UB. Although these instruments often give quality, objective information, I was noticing that people were still ‘putting people in boxes’ – I would often hear comments like: - ‘Yes they are a typical extrovert, always taking over the conversation’ or ‘Look at them playing to type just as their report says’ and other methods of categorisation equally as limiting. It’s almost as if the results that were meant to liberate your self-awareness and help you grow were having the opposite effect! My quest was to see if we could be more holistic and inclusive of the person and to recognise that they are far more complex that any report or instrument could define. I also understand that the moment you start any type of categorisation or comparison, you have started the ‘reductionist’ process but I guess it’s about how far you go before you lose the essence of the person; constant reduction to the common denominator doesn’t always give you the richest answer.

The last 6yrs yielded the creation of a holistic-person tool called Archeotype© which uses Jung’s work on Archetypes and with this I designed a broader, deeper and experiential look into people.

What became of particular interest on my journey was the concept of an Archetype - meaning an ‘ancient pattern’. Jung suggested that these were templates ‘...exist in our minds before conscious thoughts and shape our perception of our realities and experiences’ (The Psychology Book, 2012) and ‘much of what we generally attribute to deliberate, reasoned conscious thinking is being guided by Archetypes’ (ibid).

With this in mind, it started to shape my perception of nature Vs nurture in a different way. Maybe some of our UB is a result of something totally unconscious to us? Maybe, the things we think and feel are being driven by ancient patterns totally beyond our control? Maybe these Archetypes are acting as templates with pre-set biases? If this is the case, as Jung suggested, then it creates a strong argument for nature as our baseline along with our UB’s and nurture acting as a function to either confirm or deny them?

Regardless of how much our UB is ‘pre-programmed’, we know from the world of neuroscience that our brains have immense amounts of ‘plasticity’ and can be ‘re-programmed’ to change values, beliefs, behaviours, attitudes and skills – including our UB. Ultimately, there are very few excuses for not making changes to unwanted biases however the first step is to be aware of them and their source and then start the journey of reviewing and amending them as necessary.
In my next blog we’ll take a look at one of the archetypes in more detail to explore how UB’s could be formed and what we can do to address them.